Five men who spent decades in Ohio prisons for a 1992 Toledo killing they did not commit are in line for $10.2 million from the state. Court filings show Ohio has agreed to settlements with all five, days after Lucas County judges formally declared them wrongfully imprisoned. The deals still need several sign-offs before any money is paid.

Who would be paid, and how much

Under the proposed settlements, Eric Misch, Louis Costilla Jr. and Joseph Rickard would each receive $2.9 million. Brothers Ismael and Lorenzo Vasquez would each receive $750,000. Ismael Vasquez spent 32 years behind bars and his older brother spent 22, and each of the five men served at least 20 years.

The agreements must still be approved by the Ohio attorney general, the Ohio Court of Claims and the state Controlling Board before they become final. Ohio law sets compensation for wrongful imprisonment at a fixed amount for each year served, plus lost wages and certain costs.

A 1992 killing in Wilson Park

Vernon Huggins, 31, was found beaten to death in Toledo's Wilson Park on Aug. 4, 1992. The five men were sent to prison in 1993. Misch, Costilla and Rickard were convicted at trial, while the Vasquez brothers entered Alford pleas, which let a defendant maintain innocence while accepting a conviction. Misch was 16 when he confessed.

Years later, police records that had never been turned over to the defense came to light, and DNA testing in 2022 on a broken bottle found at the scene pointed toward other suspects. The convictions were vacated in December 2024, and prosecutors dismissed all charges in January 2025. No one else has been charged in Huggins' death.

What happens next

On Nov. 16, Lucas County Common Pleas judges Ian English and Stacy Cook signed filings declaring the five men "wrongfully imprisoned individuals" under Ohio law, the step that opened the door to state compensation. The Northwest Ohio Innocence Clinic told 13abc it is the first such declaration in Lucas County.

The Lucas County Prosecutor's Office said it gave the defense everything it received from law enforcement at the time, and only learned during later hearings that some documents had never reached it. The men also have a separate federal lawsuit pending against the City of Toledo and more than a dozen former officers and detectives. The state settlements do not resolve that case.

More from Ohio ↗